I have been reading Ray Dalio’s LinkedIn posts before this book came out so I wasn’t sure if I should buy it. Well, I am glad that I did and I recommend that you do too.
The book and the accompanying website https://economicprinciples.org/ have a lot to offer. Previously, one of the biggest comments from me previously was that I wished he could share more raw data or make the graphs more precise so that we can interpret/gauge the timing better. He did all of that and even more with the book and the website. He also shared this summary video recently “principles for dealing with the changing world order“. So if you don’t have a lot of time and just want to get the gist of the book, the video is a good option. All the graphs or quotes below are from the book or the website of course.
(FYI, you can download all the graphs in the book here).
So what did I learn from this book and the website?
- The US is now at about 70% of a typical great empire cycle with plus or minus 10%. It is in the decline phase of the cycle.
- China is on the other hand, in the rise phase of the cycle.
A more detailed version of the empire cycle is below
If you go deeper a bit, the story is a lot more nuanced than you think though. Using the data from the “country power index Jan 2022“, we can see that while the US is in relative decline, it is still very strong as an empire in comparison to China and extremely strong compared to other countries
Ray and his team break down the overall empire score into its individual components and share their readings on the same website. What I would love to see here is a Peer review! I don’t have the capacity, expertise or bandwidth to do a thorough peer review of the data published by Ray and his team on https://economicprinciples.org but someone should!
This way, we can have a much more meaningful debate, validate Ray’s findings/scores, or dispute it.
When we put the detailed individual scores for the US and China next to each other, this is what we see as of Jan 2022.
We can see that while the gap between the US and China is reducing across many scores, the US is still very strong in education, trade, innovation & technology, military strength, etc… China’s economic/financial position, and internal order (wealth/value gap, internal conflict) are significantly better than the US.
The immense value that I have gained from the above simple table is that:
- Some people only talk about the high indebtedness of the US, the money printing, the internal disorder (large wealth/opportunity/values gap) and conclude that the US is heading for trouble at any moment now.
- On the flip side, some people cite very strong education (with most global leading universities are in the US), high level of innovation, strong financial center, many of the most valuable companies in the world are US MNCs, etc… as examples of the US strength and dismiss the idea that the US in in decline.
- Well they are both right and wrong 🙂 both side look at part of the picture and not the whole picture. And they are not looking at the speed of change (speed of increase or decrease) and the direction of change also.
- This systematic way of seeing things is highly valuable so thank you very much Ray and his team!
If you ask me what I don’t like about the book and I have to nitpick, it is about the use of words like “timeless” or “universal”. What Ray shares in the book are about history, human beings, not the law of nature, not physics or math so I think the use of words like “timeless” is not warranted. But again, this is a very minor detail and it doesn’t impact my overall impression of the book that much.
In conclusion, a good read but a Peer review of the numbers/models are needed as the topic is too important for us all.
P.S: if you want to listen to the conversations between Ray Dalio and others (like Henry Kissinger, Larry Summers, Fareed Zakaria, or Hank Paulson) you can watch those Youtube videos here.